Overfishing is their ancestral right!

Or maybe we should just protect the salmon from all people.

What evidence do you need of the wealthy consuming more than the poor? All you have to do is open your eyes and look around you.

I never disputed carbon taxes work, you dong dong.

I just think the middle class shouldn’t be footing the bill for it while the billionaires have 12 mansions.

Don’t you think the people who have the most wealth and the most power should also be taking the most responsibility?

You know what, I’m sick of being told to take responsibility for a problem created by people thousands of times more wealthy and powerful than myself.

Why should people who can’t even afford homes be paying carbon taxes while the wealthy fly around in private jets and build mega yachts?

Fuck this backwards ass thinking.

You know how corporations and the wealthy generate the majority of carbon emissions?

Well maybe they should also be paying the majority of carbon taxes.

9:07am and tell me to return 15 minutes after and I’d be pulling out my phone every 5 seconds and doing math.

Is it really so hard to add 15?

Not to mention they’re worse at keeping time.

You know, like the whole point of a watch.

There was a time when those productive jobs paid as well or better than white collar jobs.

Not anymore. Not unless you own the business.

Carbon pricing is not intended to redistribute wealth.

Then what’s the fucking point. Wealth distribution is core of all problems in society.

we also don’t have evidence of this.

Wrong. You can literally do it with your own taxes. Go look up the corporate taxes for any public company (they’re public so they publish those numbers), and figure out what percentage of that company’s total wealth it is. Then compare that with how much tax you paid as a percentage of your total wealth.

You can even do it with billionaires because some of them, like musk, actually voluntarily share that info. Last year I paid over 20% of my total wealth in income tax alone, musk paid less 4%.

Aren’t corporations exempt from the tax and allowed to buy carbon credits at a much lower price instead? And aren’t entire industries exempt, like agriculture (the single largest generator of carbon emissions in Canada)?

And don’t those rebates for the carbon tax stop at just $61k income for an individual? Thats barely enough to buy a 50 year old trailer in BC (and you don’t own the land it’s on) last I checked. Considering the cost of living I’m sure that “low income” cutoff is way too low.

All that amounts to middle class people who are barely making their mortgage payments paying more than corporate giants are.

When you measure tax contributions as a percentage of total wealth, corporations and ultra rich always pay less than everyone else.

Somehow I missed that you qualified those two groups as innocent and guilty.

Better to ruin the lives of a million people than to take the life of one?

You’re going to have to provide some serious philosophy to back that up.

Because the poor little corporation couldn’t possibly source another tool, or develop another manufacturing process.

Why doesn’t that letter saying anything about how the middle and lower classes are disproportionately affected by such taxes?

Let me guess, these “leading economists” are all filthy rich themselves.

If those jobs fucking paid well we wouldn’t have a problem with it.

Our low skill labour is already right here in the country. People aren’t taking those because they don’t pay enough to cover bills.

That’s some solid reframing, bro 👍

This, like every argument about executive pay, just demonstrates how overpaid those similar private sector jobs are.

You are making an argument against private sector pay, not for MP pay.

But you’re not. Trump is still living a lavish life full of excess, despite his debts.

Wealth is about lifestyle, not numbers.

We have actual data going back 30+ years that watching TV limits attention span in children and is also addictive.

Nobody gives a shit about that though. What makes tiktok so much more important?